Item data · Beta Latest recorded data review: · dated imports and field-specific reviews; acquisition coverage is incomplete · Check snapshot dates
WARRIOR · SHIELD COMPATIBILITY

Warrior weapon planning: do you need to keep a shield?

Start with the intended equipment layout. If your plan includes a shield, the main-hand candidate must support that setup. A two-handed weapon can be an alternative plan or future goal, but it cannot occupy the same active setup as a shield.

Keep the shield setup or save a two-handed alternative

Shield required: compare a compatible one-handed main hand and retain the shield. Planning Whirlwind Sword: save it as a separate two-handed goal, then include the removed shield's attributes when reviewing the change. Its 2.9 s interval does not make it one-handed.

Check type and handedness before speed

Warrior weapon records include both one-handed and two-handed alternatives
Item / typeRecorded equip levelSpeedWeapon DPSSelected recorded attributes
Linken's Sword of Mastery
One-Handed Sword
Unknown1.8 s36.94No selected attributes recorded
Whirlwind Sword
Two-Handed Sword · Two-handed
0 in source; check access2.9 s35.5216 Strength, 15 Stamina
Will of the Mountain Giant
Two-Handed Axe · Two-handed
0 in source; check access2.8 s39.4615 Strength, 14 Stamina
Old Guard Retaliator
Two-Handed Axe · Two-handed
0 in source; check access3.7 s44.325 Strength, 5 Agility, 8 Stamina
Demonbane Blade
Polearm · Two-handed
0 in source; check access3.4 s45.7438 Attack Power

These are item fields, not character damage or a ranking. A missing field is unknown, not zero. An imported level of 0 does not establish quest access or current availability.

Item references, effect text and snapshot provenance
  • Linken's Sword of Mastery (ID 11902): LibItemDB v1.2.0 Forever client scan; restrictions/requirements/extra stats: build 1.60.1.69913. Record updated 2026-10-07; build 1.60.1 (scan marker 16001) / supplemental DB2 1.60.1.69913. Forever item reference. Acquisition source not verified. Imported effect text: Chance on hit: Blasts a target for 74 to 123 Nature damage. Activation rates and interactions are not established by this text.
  • Whirlwind Sword (ID 6977): LibItemDB v1.2.0 Forever client scan; restrictions/requirements/extra stats: build 1.60.1.69913; Strength, Stamina and damage range: Forever item reference reviewed 2026-10-11. Record updated 2026-10-11; build 1.60.1 (scan marker 16001) / supplemental DB2 1.60.1.69913. Forever item reference. Whirlwind Weapon — choose one quest reward (source reviewed 2026-10-11). Forever quest database and current Forever level-30 Warrior guide; source review, not an in-game observation
  • Will of the Mountain Giant (ID 10652): LibItemDB v1.2.0 Forever client scan; restrictions/requirements/extra stats: build 1.60.1.69913. Record updated 2026-10-07; build 1.60.1 (scan marker 16001) / supplemental DB2 1.60.1.69913. Forever item reference. Acquisition source not verified.
  • Old Guard Retaliator (ID 208222): LibItemDB v1.2.0 Forever client scan; restrictions/requirements/extra stats: build 1.60.1.69913. Record updated 2026-10-07; build 1.60.1 (scan marker 16001) / supplemental DB2 1.60.1.69913. Forever item reference. Acquisition source not verified.
  • Demonbane Blade (ID 275742): LibItemDB v1.2.0 Forever client scan; restrictions/requirements/extra stats: build 1.60.1.69913. Record updated 2026-10-07; build 1.60.1 (scan marker 16001) / supplemental DB2 1.60.1.69913. Forever item reference. Acquisition source not verified.

Worked decision: Whirlwind Sword is a separate setup

Whirlwind Sword records 2.9 s speed, 35.52 weapon DPS and two-handed use. Its speed does not make it a one-handed tank weapon. If your next activity requires your shield, keep a compatible one-handed main hand in Current Gear and retain the sword only as a separate goal.

If you deliberately switch to the two-handed setup, review the Off Hand removal before applying the change. Compare the complete resulting equipment layout, including the removed shield's recorded attributes. Looking only at the weapon DPS difference omits that change.

Why weapon speed does not establish threat per second

The official October 8 Forever development post, rechecked October 23, describes corrections to Rage gained from damage taken and a correction to Demoralizing Shout threat. That is direct evidence that these mechanics require version-specific treatment. It does not provide a formula for ranking the weapons in this table.

For a threat comparison, retain your current ability tooltips, talent build, target level, equipment and combat observations. A fast weapon interval alone does not prove more usable Rage, higher sustained threat or an attack that cannot be avoided.

How to compare survivability without an invented cap

Compare the recorded Stamina, Armor, Defense and shield attributes in the complete plans. Keep target level and active buffs with any in-game observations. This table does not establish a universal defense threshold, immunity to critical strikes, damage reduction percentage or raid readiness.

  1. Set Warrior, your intended specialization and actual level in Gear Planner.
  2. Choose the weapon-and-shield layout first; inspect the type and requirements of each candidate.
  3. Add a two-handed option as a goal, then review the equipment change before replacing Current Gear.
  4. Save shield and two-handed setups under separate names so the comparison includes the Off Hand difference.

The other imported records are comparison examples, not verified pre-raid rewards. Expand the provenance section to see which acquisition paths and requirements are unresolved.

Build the two setups side by side

A tank plan that only lists one weapon hides the decision that matters, because switching between a shield setup and a two-handed setup changes the Off Hand as well as the Main Hand. Build both arrangements in Gear Planner and save them under separate names, so the comparison includes the whole layout. Open the Protection Gear Planner with your actual level, record your shield setup in one plan with a compatible one-handed main hand in Current Gear, and record the two-handed alternative in a second plan. The worked example in this guide uses Whirlwind Sword, which records 2.9 s speed, 35.52 weapon DPS and two-handed use. Its speed does not make it a one-handed tank weapon, and a direct DPS comparison with Linken’s Sword of Mastery at 36.94 weapon DPS and a 1.8 s interval omits the removed shield’s recorded attributes, so compare the complete resulting equipment layouts instead. Then check the Protection Warrior BiS page for how the specialization ranks the main-hand and shield slots. If the next activity requires your shield, keep the shield plan active and retain the two-handed weapon only as a goal.

The two-handed records are not tank rankings

The remaining records in the table are two-handed weapons with larger weapon-DPS fields, and none of them is a tank ranking. Will of the Mountain Giant records 39.46 weapon DPS at 2.8 s with 15 Strength and 14 Stamina. Old Guard Retaliator records 44.32 weapon DPS at 3.7 s with 5 Strength, 5 Agility and 8 Stamina. Demonbane Blade records the highest weapon DPS in the table at 45.74 with a 3.4 s interval and 38 Attack Power, as a polearm. A higher weapon-DPS field does not establish better tanking: the table records no threat-per-second value, no defense threshold and no damage-reduction figure. All three records also carry an imported level of 0 and an unverified acquisition source in the current catalog, so none of them can be treated as a confirmed pre-raid reward on the record alone. Read them as comparison examples with different speeds, types and attribute mixes, keep the shield question separate from the DPS column, and confirm requirements and availability in game before any of them becomes a goal.

Verify before the December 9 opening

The raids open on December 9, with Barrow Deeps, Hyjal Summit and Onyxia on the schedule, so a Protection Warrior should finish the tank checks before that date rather than during the first pull. First, confirm the equip requirements for each candidate in game, and treat any record with an imported level of 0 as unverified until that check is done. Second, open Weapon Finder with Warrior, Protection and your actual level, and compare one candidate at a time against the main hand you actually use, with the shield held constant. Third, remember what the October 8 Forever development post actually establishes: it describes corrections to Rage gained from damage taken and to Demoralizing Shout threat, which is direct evidence that these mechanics need version-specific treatment, but it provides no formula for ranking the weapons in this table. For a threat comparison, retain your current ability tooltips, talent build, target level, equipment and combat observations. Save the reviewed shield and two-handed setups under separate names and export a backup. For the level-30 weapon decision behind the Whirlwind example, see the level-30 Warrior weapon guide.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to keep a shield?

If your plan includes a shield, the main-hand candidate must support that setup. A two-handed weapon cannot occupy the same active setup as a shield.

Can I plan Whirlwind Sword while keeping my shield?

Save it as a separate two-handed goal, then include the removed shield’s attributes when reviewing the change. Its 2.9 s interval does not make it one-handed.

What should I check before comparing weapon DPS?

Check type and handedness first. The records include one-handed and two-handed alternatives, and speed alone does not establish threat per second.

Are these weapon records a ranking?

No. These are item fields, not character damage or a ranking. A missing field is unknown, not zero.

Is Demonbane Blade the best tank weapon in this table?

No ranking is established here. Demonbane Blade records the highest weapon DPS in the table at 45.74 with a 3.4 s interval and 38 Attack Power, but it is a two-handed polearm with an unverified acquisition source. Weapon DPS alone does not rank tanking, so compare the complete shield and two-handed setups instead.

Can I use Will of the Mountain Giant with a shield?

No. Will of the Mountain Giant is recorded as a two-handed axe, so equipping it conflicts with an occupied Off Hand. If your next activity requires a shield, keep a compatible one-handed main hand in Current Gear and save the axe as a separate two-handed goal.

What does the Protection BiS page add to this guide?

It ranks pre-raid gear for the Protection specialization by slot, including main-hand and shield positions, while this guide shows how to read the underlying weapon records. Use the BiS ranking to choose candidates, then verify each candidate's requirements in game and compare the complete shield and two-handed setups in Gear Planner.

Source dates and editorial corrections

Editorial correction: . Whirlwind Sword was incorrectly discussed as a slow one-handed weapon. It is two-handed. The unsupported Heroic Strike avoidance claim and fixed defense-cap advice have also been removed. Presentation updated October 26; item fields and cited historical posts retain their existing review dates.